One of history’s most famous haunted houses casts a long shadow in My Amityville Horror. Eric Walter’s tantalizing doc should please both believers and die-hard skeptics.“
— The Hollywood Reporter
Eric Walter’s absorbing documentary My Amityville Horror stands apart from most Amityville-alia. He explores the hoax-or-horror debate, but his chief concern is the effect of a world-famous haunting on one of the people who experienced it.
— LA Times
My Amityville Horror is extremely well-done. This is the definitive Amityville Horror story.
— Film Threat
My Amityville Horror is a seriously fascinating film, impressively structured and absolutely absorbing.
— Screen Daily